This post originated from an RSS feed registered with .NET Buzz
by Peter G Provost.
Original Post: PDC - Weblogging the Future of Conversational Software
Feed Title: Peter Provost's Geek Noise
Feed URL: /error.aspx?aspxerrorpath=/Rss.aspx
Feed Description: Technology news, development articles, Microsoft .NET, and other stuff...
At 10pm, Jamie, Paolo and
I headed to the Weblogging BOF being hosted by Robert
McLaws. This was without a doubt the most lively BOF I've been in yet. I shouldn't
have been surprised... the room was full of extroverted tech bloggers!
This discussion covered a number of topics during its official hour. There was a significant
discussion about ATOM vs
RSS. The general consensus was that the committe based design that is going on now
needs to stop and someone needs to commit. In that regard, I said to the floor, "I
move that Clemens and Scott implement it as written and let's move on." The motion
was moved and seconded, and passed anonymously.
Yeah, right. :)
There was also a heated discussion about how to best categorize content. Mark
Canter (the father of Macromedia Director) was loud and opinionated about how
he felt that central servers will solve all the problems. Most of the rest of us rejected
this idea. One of the things that I (and many others) like about blogging is that
I have control over my content.
Clemens threw out the idea that cross-posting (a new feature in dasBlog that lets
you post the same entry to multiple blog servers) would solve this problem. I think
Clemens was saying that we would have servers for specific topical areas (e.g. Longhorn
Blogs). Then if you post to that server, you are effectively categorizing your
content.
Again, I'm not a big fan of this. After the meeting ended, a number of us stayed for
another hour talking through the issues. Harry, Chris and I spent a lot of time thinking
about how the Feed Aggregator could categorize for you. My idea is to use Bayesian
filters as the engine behind what amounts to Search Folders (ala Outlook 2K3).
Say you subscribe to 2000 feeds (or if you're Scoble... 6000). You should be able
to create a new filter folder called "Longhorn". Then you start dragging blog entries
into it. Everytime you drag a message into the folder, the bayesian filter adds that
to the good list for that folder. Conversely, if you drag a message out of a filter
folder, it adds that message to the bad list. Simple to work with, easy to train and
it should let you have a nice user-controlled way of organizing content. Filter folders
are basically virtual views onto the actual feeds themselves, so these drag and drop
operations don't cause things to move physically. They just cause the rules to update.
I think Chris and Harry liked my idea, but Chris had an even crazier idea. Can we
use the links in a post to categorize it. In other words, the fact that this post
links to Scoble could make your feed aggregator show you this post. You may not even
subscribe to my feed. This really becomes a way of analyzing the edges of the graph
instead of the nodes. My graph theory is a bit rusty, so I'll leave it to someone
else to figure this out.
I'm going to play around with the Bayesian search filters. Since SharpReader isn't
open source, I guess I'll have to start from scratch (although I may try to do it
with RSS Bandit). We'll see.
I ran out of there at 12:05am and just made the last bus at 12:15am. Fell into bed
and just barely remembered to set my alarm for 6:30.