This post originated from an RSS feed registered with Python Buzz
by Dmitry Dvoinikov.
Original Post: No sense in sensors
Feed Title: Things That Require Further Thinking
Feed URL: http://feeds.feedburner.com/ThingsThatRequireFurtherThinking
Feed Description: Once your species has evolved language, and you have learned language, [...] and you have something to say, [...] it doesn't take much time, energy and effort to say it. The hard part of course is having something interesting to say.
-- Geoffrey Miller
I like buttons. I like handles. I like dials. I like doorknobs. I like doors for that matter. I like physical controls whose shape and feel suggests their usage and whose usage provides physical feedback. If it clicks, budges and moves, then it's good. When it is in expected position and its usage is apparent from its form, then it's good.
Sensor controls makes no sense to me. I hate smearing fingers against black glossy surface, with unclear outcome. Did it work ? Did I activate the right icon ? I hate it when controls are not really controls, but images on the glass. I hate it when controls change their places, look and functions depending on what I am doing.
Even my stove is black and glossy, with no buttons but tiny engraved white icons. Makes it easy to clean for sure, but using it feels nowhere like pressing a button. Oh well, at least the icons are always in same positions.
iPhone, yes I tried it. Could have spoken through a cigarette case instead. Doesn't feel like phone at all. Large flat nothing.
Now, why sensor controls are so popular these days then ?
The way I see it, sensor controls are cheap alternative to good interface design. See, if they knew what this thing would be used for, they could have spent time and money on design and give it a nice interface, specifically for its function.
But there is a problem - they don't know what the thing will be used for. Instead they plan to use it for something no one could imagine at the moment. And they don't want to cast it in stone. They want to leave their options open, so that the interface can be changed later through software update.
From the manufacturer point of view, the sensor panel is the ideal instrument to implement any interface they may need in the future. It is a way to secure investments, rather than make it more pleasant to use. And the rest is nothing but fashion, done through professional advertising, product placement and bandwagon effect.
Ideally, people need to be placed in a world with indifferent black walls, with the content dynamically downloadable from the BigCorp site. Virtual reality, that's what it is. Opaque screens instead of windows, so that you can choose a "view". Dumb sensor panels with fake buttons. Smaller packages with more useless contents. Things that you have no control over.
Previous Topic
