This post originated from an RSS feed registered with Python Buzz
by Ben Last.
Original Post: Have It Your Way
Feed Title: The Law Of Unintended Consequences
Feed URL: http://benlast.livejournal.com/data/rss
Feed Description: The Law Of Unintended Consequences
...As Burger King allegedly say. Pondering customizability.
The inscrutable Raymond Chen's has an blog called The Old New Thing, in which he (as a Microsoft person) posts on many detailed and interesting topics related to the internals of Windows. Even if you're a Unixite so fervent that your car has a command line, it's worth reading to see why certain things in Windows are they way that they are. He has a recent entry on Why can't the default drag/drop behavior be changed? (in Explorer) which highlights something I was thinking about recently; the twin and somewhat opposed worldviews regarding interfaces.
When, in the past, I've run Linux desktops[0], I've spent happy hours playing with the myriad subtle and singular configuration options that let me set it up just how I like it, with all my favourite key and mouse combinations spread across all the applications that I need to use. Windows, naturalmente, doesn't let me do that. It works how it works. The rationale for this, according to Raymond is:
[customization] removes some of the predictability from the user interface. One of the benefits of a common user interface is that once you learn it, you can apply the rules generally. But if each user could customize how drag/drop works, then the knowledge you developed with drag/drop wouldn't transfer to other people's machines.
Further:
Infinite customizability also means that you can't just sit down in front of somebody's machine and start using it. You first have to learn how they customized their menus, button clicks, default drag effects, and keyboard macros.
I'm not sure where I'd stand on this point. I like things the way I like them, but I also hate sitting down at an unfamiliar system and not having things ready-to-hand. Perhaps it's a question of ownership of the machine in question...
[0] No axe to grind here, it's just that all my Linux systems are servers these days.
Previous Topic
